The much under rated male Koi

Posted 10 Aug 2009 - 22:16 by Mark Gardner

I wish I had 1000yen for every time I've been asked, 'is it female?', over the years.

At the 2008 ZNA All Japan Show, the Koi below came 3rd in the Grand Champion voting.  It is a male Koi of over 85cm.

At the time I thought that it's coming so close to the GC title, it was in fact may favourite, was potentially a unique achievement.

Whilst at Maruju Koi Farm the other day I was flicking through some old magazines, one was, I think, from 1996 and included winners of that years All Japan Koi Show.  I spotted a Sanke which I was sure I recognised as an All Japan GC but in the magazine it was listed as Superior Male Champion.  I presumed I was mistaken.

Sitting at my desk yesterday evening I glanced at the posted of the past 40 All Japan GC's hanging on my wall - http://www.niigata-nishikigoi.com/node/329.

Sure enough, the Sanke I'd seen the previous day was in the bottom right hand corner, the 1999 GC, bred by Takeda Koi Farm, and a male Koi.

Looking at the other GC's the 1988 GC, also bred by Takeda Koi Farm, was also a male Koi, as was the 1981 GC bred by Ryuji Nagashima of Niigata.

Looking at the earlier champions some may also have been male, I don't know when the male class was introduced, their sex is not stated.

The fact that a male Koi has taken GC at the All Japan Show as recent as 10 years ago was something I really was unaware of and took me by complete surprise.

Whilst I realise that these male Koi are somewhat of an exception it still beats me why so many hobbyists are insistent on wanting female Koi when male Koi offer a number of advantages.

This will be the subject of an article to be continued in Niigata-Nishikigoi Digest in the coming months.

The last 3 images are from Gekkan Nishikigoi published by Kinsai Publishing.



April 2009 Koi Carp

Mark,

 

I wrote a piece for the April 2009 Koi Carp magazine on this very subject. Using examples of Male koi pretty much as you have here. Trouble is i feel that while some male koi can be exceptional - the numbers of these are so limited. 

I wouldn't want a pond full of skinny males as they simply lack any kind of presence but if you could pick the right ones.... then again does that then lead to the fact that the breeders will still want to keep the best ones back and so they still attract a premium.

I guess the question is - Is the average Male koi better than the average Female koi?

Posted by Greg on 11. August 2009 - 18:02
Male v Female

Greg

I've been tapping away at this drum since 2003 after a discussion myself and Andrew G had with Micheo Maeda, President of Momotaro, one evening over dinner in his home.

I'll expand on it more in NN.com Digest in a month or 2.

I'd be interested to read your article.

Mark

Posted by Mark Gardner on 11. August 2009 - 18:40
Mark,   Kinda rushing today

Mark,

 

Kinda rushing today but i'll try to sort you a scan of the article and send it over to you in the next day or two. If you've not had and E-mail from me by the end of the week - send me one to remind me.

 

Regards,

Greg.

Posted by Greg on 11. August 2009 - 20:50